Game hunting is a very ancient practice. Today, it is practiced widely as a sport and hobby. Crossbows are commonly used to shoot deer and other wild game. A crucial part of a crossbow arrow is the broadhead. It is the part that hits and penetrates the hide of the animal. A high-quality broadhead is required to ensure accuracy and optimum power delivery while hunting. Having the best broadheads for crossbows, therefore, becomes inevitable. You do not want a broadhead that cannot subdue the animal. In fact, it is considered inhumane to do that. Broadheads are an important part of your amour if you hope to make a kill with your crossbow.

Game hunting enthusiasts are many out there. The demand for broadheads is huge too. There are many types of broadheads being made today. If you conduct searches related to best broadheads for crossbows, you will most likely be left confused. In as much as this gives you a variety to choose from, choosing the best crossbow broadheads 2018 may prove to be a daunting task. It doesn’t have to be that difficult though. We tasked ourselves with helping you identify the best broadhead for your crossbow. This is a review of different broadheads, that highlights their features, strength, and weaknesses. It will ensure you are armed with the best crossbow broadheads next time you go hunting. First, below is a comparison table of the various broadheads reviewed.

Best Broadheads For Crossbows 2018

NamepriceWeight (grain)Blade ThicknessCutting Diameter (inches)
Swhacker 100 Grain BroadheadCheck Price100.032-
New Archery Spitfire BroadheadCheck Price100.0301 -1/2’’
Swhacker Set BroadheadCheck Price100.032-
Muzzy Bowhunting Trocar BroadheadCheck Price100.0351 – 3/16’’
Rocket Steelhead BroadheadCheck Price100-1 – 1/8’’
Excalibur Bolt Cutter BroadheadCheck Price150-1 – 1/16’’
Grim Reaper Razor Tip BroadheadCheck Price100.0352’’
Muzzy Bowhunting Phantom BroadheadCheck Price100/125.036/.0401 – 1/8’’
Allen Three Blade BroadheadCheck Price125.0271 – 3/16’’
Muzzy BowhuntingBroadheadCheck Price100/125.020’’1 – 3/16’’

1) Swhacker 100 Grain Broadhead

best crossbow broadheadsSwhacker crossbow broadheads are very popular. This model weighs 100 grain and comes with 2-blades. The blades open up extremely fast. The blades are razor sharp and are strong enough to deliver a devastating impact on the target. The broadhead is made of anodized aircraft aluminum, which is light but very tough. This allows the broadhead to travel through the air fast but deliver a very powerful impact.

Core Features

  • The broadhead weights 100 grain
  • It has two blades
  • The blades are .032’’ thick
  • The blades are made of stainless steel
  • The broadhead’s body is made of anodized aircraft aluminum
  • It has a hardened carbon steel point

Pros

  • The broadhead has tough and strong materials
  • The blades open up very fast
  • The broadheads hit the target with a high power
  • The hardened steel tip effectively penetrates the target’s hide
  • It leaves a very clear blood trail

Cons

  • The broadhead comes with bands to hold the blades in place. The bands wear out quickly and are too small at times.

Opinion

This broadhead seems like effective and powerful broadhead. There is no negative review about it on Amazon too. The broadhead can deliver an impressive performance. It could be a great addition to your armor collections. It delivers very powerful hits on the targets, and leaves a clear blood trail, ensuring the animal does not get lost.

Check Latest Price

2) New Archery Spitfire Broadhead

best broadhead arrowThe Spitfire broadhead from new archery is yet another impressive broadhead. It weighs 100 grain and has a 1 ½’’ cutting diameter. That is enough diameter to tear up the hide of a big animal, leaving a clear blood trail. The broadhead is made of tough and hard materials, that ensure it delivers great speed and powerful impact on the target.

Core Features

  • The broadhead weighs 100 grain
  • It has 1 ½’’ cutting diameter
  • It comes with a micro-grooved slimline ferrule
  • It has front-deploying blades
  • The blades are .030’’ thick
  • The blades are diamine sharpened
  • It features a hardened trophy tip

Pros

  • The broadhead travels fast through the air
  • It delivers a powerful bone-crushing impact
  • The materials used are lightweight, but tough and strong
  • The diamine sharpened tip helps it penetrate the hide of the target effectively
  • The cutting diameter is wide enough to allow and a clear blood trail

Cons

  • The broadhead suffers from cases of blades not deploying. This largely affects the effectiveness of such a broadhead

Verdict

The Spitfire broadhead suffers several concerning complaints about blades not deploying. If the blades do not deploy the impact on the target might not be much, and there will most likely be no blood trail. Such target will get lost easily, even after being hit. This put blemish on what would, otherwise, have been extremely amazing broadheads. The positive reviews about it are many though. The complaints may, therefore, be isolated cases. The broadhead, therefore, deserves consideration as one of the best broadheads for your best broadhead arrow.

Check Latest Price

3) Swhacker Set Broadhead

best broadheadsWe have yet another broadhead from the Swhacker series. This model does not fall any short of the previous one. It has the same tough and strong materials that translate into a powerful and devastating shot on a target. This broadhead is 100 grain in weight and comes with two blades which are .032’’ thick. The blades protrude 1 inch while closed and 2 inches while open.

Core Features

  • The broadhead weighs 100 grain
  • It has two blades that are .032’’ in thickness
  • The blades are 1inch while closed and 2 inches while open
  • It features a steel carbon-hardened tip
  • The body is made of anodized aircraft aluminum

Pros

  • The broadhead delivers fast speeds and powerful impact
  • It was tough, durable and strong materials
  • The blades are razor sharp
  • The blades are expandable; that convenient. You can expand them to deliver more devasting impact on a bigger animal

Cons

  • The broadhead leaves a minimal blood trail or even none.

Opinion

Trust the Swhacker broadheads to drop that big deer within seconds. This broadhead does not leave a clear blood trail though. This may sound concerning to many people. However, the kind of devastating impact it delivers on the target might not require the blood trail at all. This broadhead will hit targets with tremendous power, subduing them within no time. It should be one of your top-of-the-list options.

Check Latest Price

4) Muzzy Bowhunting Trocar Broadhead

crossbow broadheads for deerMuzzy broadheads are also very popular. Muzzy has been making broadheads for a while now. The Bowhunting Trocar is one of their very popular models. The broadhead delivers some of the most powerful impacts. The broadhead can come in either 100 grain or 125 grain. It has .035’’ thick helix blade. The blades are razor sharp and tears through the hide and internal organs of the target while tremendous power and ease. The blades are also designed to ensure optimum shot accuracy.

Core Features

  • The broadhead comes in either 100 grain or 125 grain
  • It has three blades
  • It has .035’’ thick helix blades
  • The broadhead has a 1 3/16’’ cutting diameter

Pros

  • The broadhead delivers powerful impacts
  • It leaves a clear blood trail
  • The blades are thick but very sharp. They tear through the target with ease
  • The blades are designed for maximum accuracy

Cons

  • The 125 grain is a bit heavy. It might not be effective if your crossbow is designed for a lighter broadhead.

Opinion

The Muzzy Bowhunting Trocar broadhead is a top of the range broadhead. If you are a passionate game hunting enthusiast, this is the kind of broadhead you need on your arrows. This broadhead will subdue a deer in seconds, and you won’t even need the blood trails. Your targets will be dead before they even know what hit them if you have this broadhead on your arrows. Many argue that hunting with an ineffective broadhead is inhumane to the animals. This is your broadhead is that’s your line of thinking. This is the best broadhead for deer.

Check Latest Price

5) Rocket Steelhead Broadhead

best crossbow broadheads 2018The people who named this broadhead Rocket steelhead were not wrong by any means. It cruises through the air at rocket speeds to deliver a very powerful impact on your target. The broadhead weighs 100 grain, and it has an extremely strong broadhead. This broadhead is also optimized towards being accurate. Your chances of missing your target are greatly reduced if you have this broadhead. It has a scalloped ferrule with a minimal surface area, to ensure minimal wind drag and high speed.

Core Features

  • The broadhead weights 100 grain
  • It has a 1 1/8’’ cutting diameter
  • It has a solid steel ferrule

Pros

  • The broadhead has a very strong steelhead
  • It travels at supersonic speeds, to deliver powerful impacts on the targets
  • The broadhead has high accuracy
  • The materials used are tough and strong

Cons

  • The broadhead does not fit well in a quiver
  • It does not leave a clear blood trail

Opinion

The Rocket Steelhead broadhead delivers high accuracy and a powerful impact and probably won’t need the blood trail. The high speeds and accuracy, ensure that broadhead hits the target with tremendous power at the most appropriate place, to subdue it immediately. The broadhead has a very strong and sharp steelhead that penetrates through the target’s hide with ease.

Check Latest Price

6) Excalibur Bolt Cutter Broadhead

best crossbow mechanical broadheads 2018Excalibur crossbows are very popular and effective. We, therefore, expected nothing less from Excalibur broadheads. The Excalibur Bolt Cutter is a 150 grain broadhead, with a cutting diameter of 1 1/16’’. The broadhead has a high-strength stainless steel construction, that will deliver a powerful impact on the target. This broadhead is yet another high-speed broadhead, and it is appropriate for equally high-speed crossbows.

Core Features

  • The broadhead weighs 150 grain
  • It has a high strength stainless steel construction
  • It is used with high-speed crossbows
  • It has a cutting diameter of 1 1/16’’

Pros

  • The broadhead has powerful impacts
  • It has tough and strong materials
  • It leaves a clear blood trail
  • It speeds, hence more accuracy

Cons

  • The broadhead might be too heavy for many crossbows.

Opinion

The Excalibur Bolt Cutter is a strong and high-speed broadhead. It has good weight and speed, which are bound to deliver a very powerful impact on the target. The broadhead has high accuracy too. High speeds help increase accuracy. This crossbow qualifies to be one of your options if you are considering getting a crossbow soon.

Check Latest Price

7) Grim Reaper Razor Tip Broadhead

crossbow broadheadsThe Grim Reaper Razor Tip broadhead, just as the name suggests, is optimized towards reaping the target’s hide and internal organs apart to ensure it is subdued within minutes. The 100 grain broadhead comes with three blades. It has a 2’’ cutting diameter that will leave a very clear blood trail. The animal is getting lost after you have landed a shot on it. It has high speeds and powerful impact.

Core Features

  • The broadhead weighs 150 gains
  • It has three blades
  • The blades are .035’’ thick
  • It has a 2’’ cutting diameter

Pros

  • The broadhead has high speeds hence more impact power and accuracy
  • It has a wide cutting diameter that ensures the animal is subdued fast
  • It leaves a very clear blood trail
  • The blades are thick and razor sharp. They reap through the animal’s hide and internal organs with ease.

Cons

  • The blades fail to deploy at times. This hugely affects the effectiveness and accuracy of the broadhead.

Opinion

The broadhead does not seem to disappoint in any way. Though there are some complaints about the blades not deploying, they seem like isolated cases. It is a high-speed, high-impact and strong broadhead. You don’t have to worry about its breaking up. You will be amazed by the size of the hole this broadhead creates on your target. An animal stands no chance of running away when you are armed with the Grim Reaper broadhead.

Check Latest Price

8) Muzzy Bowhunting Phantom Broadhead

best broadheads for crossbowsWe encounter yet another Muzzy bowhunting broadhead, the muzzy phantom. The Muzzy Phantom broadhead has four very sharp blades and 1 1/8’’ cutting diameter. The broadhead is designed to quickly subdue large wild game, by tearing through their hide and organs powerfully and with ease.

Core Features

  • The broadhead comes in either 100 grain or 125 grain
  • The 100 grain broadhead has .036’’ blades
  • The 125 grain broadhead has .040’’ blades
  • The broadhead also has .028’’ bleeder blades

Pros

  • The broadhead delivers powerful impacts
  • The broadhead ensures a clear blood trail
  • It has very sharp blades that penetrate the animal with ease
  • The broadhead has high accuracy

Cons

  • The weighty broadhead may not work well with many crossbows.

Opinion

The Muzzy Phantom broadhead has an impressive system of blades that offers wild game no survival chance. Muzzy offers 100 or 125 grain broadheads for crossbows. These blades will leave an unbelievably large hole in the animal. This is the kind of broadhead that you go hunting large animals with. It should not miss at the top of your list of options.

Check Latest Price

9) Allen Three Blade Broadhead

best crossbow broadheadsThe Allen broadhead comes with three very sharp blades. The broadhead has a cutting diameter of 1 3/16’’. The blades are .027’’ wide. It comes with a hardened and extremely sharp tip, to ensure it can penetrate the animal with ease. The broadhead weighs 125 grain.

Core Features

  • The broadhead weighs 125 grain
  • It has three blades
  • It has a cutting diameter of 1 3/16’’
  • The blades are made of stainless steel

Pros

  • The Brodhead has very sharp tip and blades
  • The materials used are tough and strong
  • The broadhead delivers a powerful impact
  • It leaves a clear blood trail

Cons

  • The broadhead is heavier than most standard broadheads. It might not work well with most crossbows

Opinion

The Allen three blade broadhead seems like a moderate performance broadhead. It is more likely to be offered at a favorable price. This broadhead is a great option for anyone looking for an effective broadhead but is on a tight budget.

Check Latest Price

10) Muzzy Bowhunting Broadhead

crossbow broadheads for deerThe last broadhead we are going to review is from the Muzzy Bowhunting series yet again. This further cements the effectiveness of the Muzzy broadheads. The broadhead is made of hardened steel, to be strong and have maximum penetration. It delivers the powerful impacts synonymous with muzzy bowheads. It has great flight stability that ensures it hits the target accurately. Its stainless-steel blades are razor sharp.

Core Features

  • The broadhead has three blades
  • It comes in either, 75, 100 or 125 grain.
  • The blades are .20’’ thick
  • The cutting diameter is 1 3/16’’ for the 100 and 125 grain broadhead, and 1’’ for the 75 grain broadhead.

Pros

  • The broadhead delivers very powerful impacts
  • The materials used are strong and tough
  • The blades are razor sharp
  • It leaves a visible blood trail.

Cons

  • The 75 grain broadhead may not have enough power.
  • The 125 grain is not suitable for many crossbows

Opinion

We close off with yet another Muzzy Bowhunting Broadhead, which is an extremely powerful broadhead. It does not disappoint in any aspects. This model is offered in different sizes, so it is versatile. The different sizes are great for different crossbows. The Muzzy Bowhunting Trocar Broadhead is, without a shadow of a doubt, a top of the range broadhead.

Check Latest Price

Best Broadheads For Crossbows 2018 – Buyer’s Guide

After going through various types of broadheads and highlighting their features, you are now better informed about what a great broadhead entails. The review has not picked out any of them as the best though. This might have you a bit confused. You need not worry! These broadheads are best suited to different circumstances. Therefore, your specific circumstances will determine which broadhead is the best for you. Let’s look at the various factors that are supposed to influence your decisions while choosing a broadhead for your crossbow.

  • Crossbow Recommendations

Each broadhead above can be used on different brands of crossbows. However, you need to ensure that the crossbow you get has the same weight as recommended on your crossbow. If you do not have that information, you can call the crossbow company an enquiry. The broadhead will not work effectively if they are heavier or lighter than what is recommended. This weight alignment affects that accuracy and impact power delivered by the broadhead.

  • Cutting Diameter

The cutting diameter of the broadhead determines that size of the hole that broadhead makes on the target. Normally, a larger hold will mean more impact on the target. This means the animal will get subdued faster.  A larger hole also translates into more bleeding, and hence a clear blood trail when the animal runs away. If the animal runs away without a blood trail, you may not be able to find it, while it may still end up dead. That would be unfortunate. Right?

  • Blades

The number and size of the blades on the broadhead also has a significant impact on how quickly you subdue your target with a shot. Bigger blades will crush bones and tear through the animal aggressively. The animal will, therefore, be subdued much faster.

  • Price

These blades are offered at varied prices. Your budget will ultimately get to determine the broadhead you get for your crossbow. Do not compromise on the quality just so that you can save a few bucks. It is prudent that you buy from reputable brands, such as the ones mentioned above. Also, be sure to compare the various broadheads that are within your budget, to ensure you get value for your money.

Conclusion

Having reviewed several crossbow broadheads, and developed a buying guide, you are now in a better position to choose the best broadhead for your crossbow. We aim at ensuring you get the best crossbow broadheads, to ensure they serve you efficiently and for longer. The debate about best crossbow mechanical broadheads 2018 should not sound confusing anymore. The review is long and detailed. It would be difficult for you to recall all the details in it. As such, below is a summary table of all the broadheads reviewed, with their respective features and prices.

NameCore FeaturesPrice
Swhacker 100 Grain Broadhead
  • 100 grain

  • 2 blades

  • Carbon hardened steel point

  • Anodized aircraft aluminum body

  • Check Price
    New Archery Spitfire Broadhead
  • 100 grain

  • Micro-groove slimline ferrule

  • Diamine sharpened blades

  • Hardened trophy tip

  • Front deploying blades

  • Check Price
    Swhacker Set Broadhead
  • 100 grain

  • 2 blades

  • Anodized aircraft aluminum body

  • Hardened steel tip

  • Check Price
    Muzzy Bowhunting Trocar Broadhead
  • 100/125 grain

  • Solid-steel ferrule

  • 3 blades

  • Helix blade design

  • Check Price
    Rocket Steelhead Broadhead
  • Scalloped ferrule with theminimal surface area

  • Solid steel head

  • 1-piece ferrule

  • Check Price
    Excalibur Bolt Cutter Broadhead
  • 150 grain

  • High-strength stainless steel construction

  • High-speed

  • Check Price
    Grim Reaper Razor Tip Broadhead
  • 100 grain

  • 3 blades

  • High-speed

  • Thick blades

  • Check Price
    Muzzy Bowhunting Phantom Broadhead
  • 100/125 grain

  • Secondary bleeder blades

  • High-speed

  • Check Price
    Allen Three Blade Broadhead
  • 3 blades

  • Hardened tip

  • 125 grain

  • Check Price
    Muzzy BowhuntingBroadhead
  • 3 blades

  • 100/125 grain

  • Stainless steel blades

  • Enhanced flight stability

  • Check Price

    See Also: